Mrs. Yoder’s Heirloom Peanut Butter Pie – An Amish Favorite

You guys, peanut butter pie has got to be one of my most favorite desserts on the planet. It’s cool, creamy, and filled with peanut buttery flavor. Who could ever ask for anything more? Now, the peanut butter pie that this midwestern chick is used to is much richer than the Amish version I am debuting today on the next page. When my Michigander mother makes a PB pie she uses cream cheese and not vanilla pudding. I actually prefer this method because I like a richer more robust PB pie.

With that being said, this Amish version of PB pie is still super amazing. The Amish certainly have a way with desserts and this Yoder’s peanut butter pie is definite proof of that.

This is the type of PB pie that my husband, a Pennsylvania native, grew up eating so he was delighted when I surprised him with this dessert. Apparently, his grandma would make peanut butter pie to sell during church bake sales. Fun!

If you are a regular reader of this blog then you know that I am a Michigan girl that was transplanted to Pennsylvania. Midwestern peanut butter pie is quite a bit different than eastern peanut butter pie. In Michigan, our PB is very robust and there isn’t any vanilla pudding in the mix but rather cream cheese. I gotta admit, I like the midwestern version better than this vanilla pudding version BUT the recipe is still yummy and I’d still eat it any day. Enjoy!

Related Post:
Creamed Chipped Beef On Toast


  • 1 Pillsbury deep dish pie shell- I just use the ones from the freezer section
  • 2 boxes of Jello vanilla pudding mix (about 1.5 oz. each)
  • 3 c. cold milk
  • 1 heaping tablespoon of peanut butter (I use creamy)
  • 1 8oz container of Cool-Whip
  • Peanut Butter Crumbs:
  • 3 tbsp. Jif peanut butter
  • 1 c. Domino powdered sugar


Bake pie shell as directed on the box, set aside.

Mix vanilla pudding and milk until thickened, add 1tbsp. peanut butter.

Mix thoroughly and place in fridge to set.

In the meantime, combine 3 tbsp. peanut butter and powdered sugar in a bowl. Use a fork to mix and continue until crumbs form.

Take pie shell and pour 1/3 of the crumbs in the bottom of the shell. Add pie filling and pour 1/3 of the crumbs on top of the filling. Spread about 1/2 a container (or more) of Cool-Whip on top of the that and add remaining crumbs on top of the Cool-Whip.

Source :

Creamy Pineapple Showoff Dessert Bars

No Bake Banana Split Dessert